If You Come at the Justice, You Best Have Sources

By Christine Anne George

It started out, as most catastrophic events do, with a simple tweet.

Should be easy enough, right? Did esteemed future jurist and Supreme Court Justice Benjamin Nathan Cardozo sit for the New York Bar Exam five agonizing times before passing on his sixth try? Not knowing anything about this allegation, I went looking for the source. The post on Before the Bar, which was included in the tweet, linked out to another post from Bar Exam Hell. Here’s where we run into a slight issue. Bar Exam Hell did not list or link out to any sources for its entry on Cardozo. Before the Bar also includes links to a few other stories. Tipping the Scale has no source listed. Buzzfeed links out to the Wall Street Journal which cites a post on the Brennan Center’s blog by Elizabeth Wurtzel. (Sidebar: Love the Wayback Machine. Love. It.) The post on The Volokh Conspiracy also goes back to the Wurtzel post, which is beginning to seem like Patient Zero for this rumor. Yes I do say rumor. Spoiler alert: it’s not true.

Here’s the thing: I love footnotes. As a writer, nothing brings me more joy than writing an article whose footnotes are so crammed with additional tangential information that they could comprise a second article. As a reader, I’m downright giddy when I see a number in superscript following an interesting sentence that will lead me to even more sources. Yes, I am that person. Even while blogging, I can go a bit hyperlink-happy. So you can imagine me working through the various stages of grief upon realizing that the “sources” for this allegation were nothing more than an echo chamber. Once I finished breathing into my paper bag and accepted that sheer force of will would not make any proper sources magically appear, I got ready to go full on librarian on this question. Now’s probably a good time to throw in that I don’t particularly care whether or not Cardozo passed the bar on the first go. There’s nothing wrong with having failed the bar, but not properly sourcing…that’s unforgivable.

With all the confidence of a reference librarian on a mission, I marched off to our shelf of Cardozo biographies. That’s right. I hit the books. Actual, physical books. Only there was a bit of a problem. I couldn’t locate any footnotes, citations, or, in some instances, even mentions, of Cardozo’s bar exam experience. As it would turn out, there was one biography that had just the footnote I needed, but at the time of the search frenzy, both of our copies were checked out.

The following is accepted (and verified) fact:

Cardozo graduated from Columbia College in 1889.[1] He continued on at Columbia’s law school.[2] Right around the end of his second year, there was a bit of a kerfuffle—the two year LLB program was being expanded into three years.[3] Cardozo, along with a few faculty and many students, did not return.[4] Cardozo has acknowledged the fact that he did not graduate from law school.[5]

At my whit’s end, I decided to phone a friend. And by a friend, I mean many wonderful librarians and archivists at a variety of institutions, which are listed at the end of this post. There was quite a bit of research drama as I found out that the NY State Bar Exam was not standardized until 1894[6] (which meant that the official record began in 1895[7]), but there was an 1871 law[8] that somewhat regulated what the bar exam should be and when it should be administered in New York. (I have to give a special shoutout to the awesome people I spoke to at the NY Board of Law Examiners who, given the time of year, would have been perfectly within their rights to hang up on the random law librarian asking about the bar exam from 1891.) However, it all ultimately came down to a footnote in Andrew L. Kaufman’s biography, Cardozo, which pointed to Box 10 of the Benjamin N. Cardozo Papers at Columbia University’s Rare Book & Manuscript Library.

If you stop by the Butler Library and request Box 10, you’ll find a folder of diplomas and awards. Within that folder is a photstat of Cardozo’s certificate of admission. It states that he took the bar on June 26, 1891 and was admitted on October 7, 1891.

Cardozo Certificate

Benjamin N. Cardozo’s New York Bar Admission Certificate, October 7, 1891, Benjamin N. Cardozo Papers, Rare Book & Manuscript Library, Columbia University in the City of New York. Reproduced with Permission.

So let’s lay this rumor to rest and remember to always, always, always cite sources, no matter what the medium. I also have some thoughts on how those sources should be formatted, but, given the fact WordPress removed all my small caps, we’ll save that for another time.

Many thanks to:

My colleagues Carolyn Brown, Kay MacKey, Richard Kim, and Carissa Vogel

Columbia University’s Rare Book & Manuscript Library, especially Tara Craig

The U.S. Supreme Court Law Library, especially Jennifer Kim

The New York City Bar Association Library

The New York State Board of Law Examiners

The New York State Archives, especially Jim Folts

Professor Norman Otto Stockmeyer

[1] “Columbia College Commencements,” NY Times, May 11, 1889.

[2] Richard Polenberg, The World of Benjamin Cardozo: Personal Values and the Judicial Process 39 (1997), citing Cardozo to Ernest Abraham Cardozo, Nov. 21, 1932, Benjamin Cardozo Papers, Rare Book & Manuscript Library, Columbia University in the City of New York.

[3] “A Student’s Protest,” NY Times, Mar. 31, 1891.

[4] Polenberg, The World of Benjamin Cardozo 39.

[5] Id.

[6] Alfred Zantzinger Reed, Training for the Public Profession of the Law: Historical Development and Principal Contemporary Problems of Legal Education in the United States with Some Account of the Conditions in England and Canada 103 (1921), available at https://ia802701.us.archive.org/5/items/trainingforpubl00goog/trainingforpubl00goog.pdf.

[7] 2 Alden Chester with E. Melvin Williams, Courts and Lawyers of New York: A History, 1609-1925, at 890 (Law Book Exchange, Ltd., 2005) (1925)

[8] 1871 N.Y. Laws 1015. Rules referenced within the law can be founded in the Appendix at 1871 N.Y. Laws 2194.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Factual & Investigative Research, Information Literacy and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to If You Come at the Justice, You Best Have Sources

  1. ottostockmeyer says:

    Thank you for putting to rest the pernicious canard that Cardozo failed the bar exam, which has been ricocheting around the blogosphere for years. To paraphrase Mark Twain, this falsehood travelled around the globe while the truth was lacing its boots. Your blog post will help stamp it out.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s